Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Lecture 20 Notes

Lecture 20 Judicial Review

This is the process by which courts are able to determine the lawfulness of executive power. It is concerned with the legality of the decision making process as opposed to the merits of the actual decision.  As we have already seen, courts are unlikely to review the lawfulness of an Act of Parliament. They are not however at all hesitant to review the lawfulness of delegated legislation. Where an Act of Parliament gives a minister a the power to make regulations, the minister may be given the power to make such regulations as he sees fit in order to give effect to the purposes of the Act of Parliament. In other words, he must intra vires rather than ultra vires.

The power of a court to review an administrative decision is given to the High Court (QBD). The court does not examine the merits of a decision, so its review is limited to the manner or the procedure by which the decision was reached. This is different from an Appeal process, in which the decision is reviewed and is substituted with a new one. In JR, the court merely looks at HOW the decision was made, whether it was fair, reasonable etc.

Also, since the passage of the HRA, 1998, a further requirement is that executive bodies or agencies must fulfill the requirements of the Human Rights Act in making their decisions. For eg, if the review is made on HR grounds, the applicant has a year to make the application. Ordinarily, applicant has three months.

Please note that this is not an automatic right – an applicant must be obtain leave from the court before he is granted permission to obtain judicial review. In addition to this, other conditions must be met:
  • Judicial Review can only be brought in respect of a public matter, not a private one:
See O’Reilly v Mackman (1983) – Judgment of Lord Diplock where it was first held that the where public law rights were at stake, the claimants could only proceed by way of judicial review. They could not originate their action under the general civil law procedure, because that would be avoiding the procedural safeguards afforded to public authorities by the judicial review procedure, such as the requirement of sufficient interest, timely submission and permission for judicial review. Applicants were punished for being part of riots at Hull prison – wanted to bring action against their punishment through an ordinary writ of summoms. Diplocks and HL hold that the action can only come via judicial review. Highly criticized decision.
  • Judicial Review can only be brought against a public body
See R v City Panel of Takeovers and Mergers, Ex Parte Datafin (1987) In this case, a privately established organ was amenable to judicial review because it in fact operated as an integral part of a governmental framework for regulating Mergers and Takeover, while those affected had no choice but to submit to its jurisdiction. Also has a good for the definition of a public body. It does not necessarily have to be one created by statute, one qualifies as a public body if you are performing a function for which, had you not existed, a public body would have had to be created.  Compare that to a Jockey Club (Ex Parte Aga Khan – where the Foundation, which owned racehorses, tries to challenge the decision of the Epsom Race holders to ban his horse after traces of a banned substance was found in its urine sample through judicial review. Court holds that JR no available here as RC performs no public function) which the court held performed no public function.
  • The issue must be justiciable – i.e. that there are certain decisions that are considered “political” and are therefore outside the courts.
Nottinghamshire County Council v Secretary of State for the Environment (1986) - Nottinghamshire CC v Secretary of State for the Environment (1986) The Labour County Council
challenged the Conservative minister for having set targets  for expenditure and thus grant distribution
that discriminated particularly against a small number of authorities, including Nottinghamshire. The
challenge was upheld by the Court of Appeal in a decision that would have overturned the
government’s whole target-based local finance policy, but was overturned when the minister appealed
to the House of Lords, where it was held that spending limits on local councils imposed by ministers is a political question.

Also – ex Parte rees mogg!
One of the issues that are typically held to not be justiciable is the application of the Royal Prerogative. However, it is for the court to decide whether or not an issue is justiciable and no one else. This is one of the key holdings of the GCHQ Case, where it was held for the first time that Prerogative powers are subject to judicial review.

  • You must have locus standi to bring a case
This means that you must have interest in the particular matter before you can bring a case:
Sufficient Interest defined by the case R v Inland Revenue, Ex Parte National Federation of Self Employed and Small Businesses (1982) As a matter of general principle I would hold that one taxpayer has no sufficient interest in asking the court to investigate the tax affairs of another taxpayer or to complain that the latter has been under-assessed or over-assessed: indeed, there is a strong public interest that he should not. And this principle applies equally to groups of taxpayers: an aggregate of individuals each of whom has no interest cannot of itself have an interest. 

I.e. You can only ask for JR if the act in question affects you personally. No busy bodies…e.g
            Schmidt v Home Secretary 1969
BuT you have standing if the Act in Question will harm the whole world R v Secretary of State for Home Affairs, Ex Parte Rees Mogg – this was on the question of whether the Maastricht Treaty could be ratified
Courts typically recognize the rights of groups to challenge the decisions of the courts.
            R v Liverpool Corporation Ex Parte Liverpool Taxi Operators Association
  • Timeousness – Application must be brought within three months of the decision – R v Secretary of State for the Environment, Ex Parte Ostler
  • Exhaustion of Other Remedies; The applicant must have no other remedy under the statute, e.g. the right to appeal – but the right to appeal can be taken away!! By Ouster and Exemption Clauses; What are these?
Exclusion or Ouster Clauses/Also called Conclusive Evidence Clauses by Burnett and Study Guide
Some statutes try to exclude the possibility of judicial review by providing that the decisions of ministers;

·         “Shall not Be Questioned”: Anismic  v Foreign Compensation Commission (1969) The commission was set up by the Foreign Compensation Act 1950. The commission decided that the claimant company had failed to establish a claim for compensation for the loss of its Egyptian assets following the Suez crisis of 1956. Challenged successfully the decision of the commission using judicial review.
·         “Shall be final”: R v Medical Appeal Tribunal, Ex Parte Gilmore (1957) In R v Medical Appeal Tribunal (ex parte Gilmore) [1957] the tribunal’s decision was quashed for error of law even though the statute in question said that the tribunal’s decision ‘shall he final’. Denning LJ said:"I find it very well settled that the remedy by certiorari is never to be taken away by any statute except by the most clear and explicit words.”

Courts have held that such clauses should be interpreted strictly – any form of ambiguity should inure to the benefit of the applicant for JR. So this language may have excluded an Appeal – but they do not exclude judicial review. However, if the language of the statute is unambiguous e.g it says:
  • The subordinate legislation shall have effect “as if enacted in this Act”
  • The decision… will be “final and conclusive” and cannot be “challenged, appealed against, reviewed, quashed, or called into question by any court of law”. South Asia Firebricks v Non-Metallic Mineral Products

  • Final Condition – the action for judicial review must fall into one three grounds for judicial review – namely; These were laid out by judgment of Diplock in the GCHQ case.
    • Illegality
    • Irrationality
    • Procedural Impropriety
The first two categories are sometimes joined under the name “unreasonableness”

Illegality:
  1. Ultra Vires:
This applies where executive is deemed to be acting ultra vires or outside of one’s lawful powers.
This happens where:-
A public body acts outside of its authority or statutory limit:
R v Richmond upon Thames City Council; Ex Parte MaCarthy and Stone (1992) –a local planning authority levies fees when it has no statutory authority to levy fees.

As a result of the passage of the HRA, A public body may act outside of its authority if is response is considered to be disproportional. R v Chief Constable of Sussex, Ex parte international trader’s Ferry (1999) – too many police people at the scene of a confrontation between live animal exporters and animal rights activists.

  1. Error of Law:

Where a public authority misinterprets its powers; Perilly v Tower Hamlets Borough Council (1973) – what it needs to take into consideration in respect of the issue of licenses
Or;
Comes to an unreasonable conclusion: Coleen Properties v Minister of Housing (1971)

Note that the distinction between an error of law and an error of fact is sometimes difficult to determine – e.g. in the Anismic case, it was held that if the error of fact was serious enough, it may result in an error of law. Also, public bodies are supposed to interpret laws based on correct facts, so if they incorrectly interpret facts, there may be court intervention to correct this. R v Hillingdon Borough Council ex Parte Pulhofer [1986] AC 484, the local authority had to provide homeless persons with accommodation. The applicants were a married couple, who lived with her two children in one room and applied to the local authority for aid. The local authority refused aid because it considered that the Pulhofers were not homeless and the House of Lords upheld this decision because whether the applicants had accommodation was a question of fact for the authority to determine.

  1. Failure to Act – where a statutory body is supposed to take a particular action but does not do
so – remedy for this is to compel the body to act with Mandamus order.

4.    Acting n bad faith – basically acting in a deliberately dishonest manner – Cannock Chase District v Kelly (1978) -

5.    Using powers improperly – e.g. of this Attorney-General v Fulham Corp 1921 – using powers as non-profit to make money instead. Supposed to open non-profit laundry and operates a commercial laundry rather.

6.    Onerous Condition – if it makes a decision that attaches such onerous conditions that it becomes difficult to perform Pyx Granite Co Ltd v Ministry of Housing (1958)

7.    Abuse of Discretion – where the illegal act stems from the authority exceeding the powers it has been granted under statute. EG

8.    Takes into Account irrelevant considerations – does not take into account irrelevant considerations . Wheeler v Leicester City Council (1985) Wheeler v Leicester City Council (1985) The City Council banned Leicester Rugby Club from using a council-owned pitch, claiming the club had not fully supported the council’s anti-apartheid policy and its opposition to any sporting contacts with South Africa. Peter Wheeler (then club captain, later its chief executive) challenged the  council’s decision, was unsuccessful in the Divisional and Appeal Courts, but had it upheld in the House of Lords, who declared the council’s action ‘unreasonable’
See also – unauthorized delegation – gives power to another authority when it is not supposed to) and Fettering Discretion – interprets its mandate in a manner that makes it impossible to act. R v Port of London Authority ex Parte Kynoch

Irrationality

The authority has based its in decision in a manner that is “so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could ever come to it”; or “a decision so outrageous in its defiance of logic or accepted moral standards that no sensible person who applied his mind to the question to be decided could have arrived at it”.
Associated Provincial Picture House v Wednesbury Corporation  (1919)
"Associated Provincial Picture Houses" were granted a licence by the defendant local authority to operate a cinema on condition that no children under 15 were admitted to the cinema on Sundays. The claimants sought a declaration that such a condition was unacceptable, and outside the power of the Wednesbury Corporation to impose. The court held that it could not intervene to overturn the decision of the defendant corporation simply because the court disagreed with it. To have the right to intervene, the court would have to form the conclusion that:
·         the corporation, in making that decision, took into account factors that ought not to have been taken into account, or
·         the corporation failed to take account factors that ought to have been taken into account, or
·         the decision was so unreasonable that no reasonable authority would ever consider imposing it.

The court held that the condition did not fall into any of these categories.
Therefore, the claim failed and the decision of the Wednesbury Corporation was upheld.

This is a very high standard to meet. The test is very rarely passed!

Especially if the public body gives reasons.

·         Secretary Of State For Education V Tamseside Council (1977)
Secretary of State for Education v Tameside MBC (1977) The newly elected Conservative-controlled
Tameside Council (Greater Manchester) abandoned the former Labour council’s planned
comprehensive reorganisation of the borough’s secondary schools shortly before its scheduled
introduction. When the Labour minister ordered that the reorganisation should proceed, the borough’s challenge was eventually upheld in the House of Lords, who ruled that the LEA’s action had not been  unreasonable’.

R v Ministry of Defence, Ex Parte Smith (Can ban homosexuals from UK army – if you give reasons)

NB – nomenclature issues around the term unreasonableness – sometimes applies to other kinds of illegality so be sure that what is being referred to is Wednesbury type unreasonableness

Procedural Impropriety
Two kinds –
  • failure to follow the laid rules and procedures under the statute tribunal is supposed to operate under ; or
  • Failure to follow the rules of natural justice
What is natural justice?
Rule against bias – nemo iudex/judex in causa sua (no one can act as a judge in their own cause) and the right to a fair hearing (audi alteram partem – listen/consider the other persons point of view)
  1. Bias
Biases may be caused by financial interest – Dimes v Grand Canal Junction (1852)
Lord Cottenham (LC) held a substantial block of shares in a canal company that brought a case in equity against a landowner. His holding was then discovered and an application made to have the Chancellor's decision set aside.Held: Although there was no suggestion that the Lord Chancellor had in fact been influenced by his interest in the company, no case should be decided by a judge with a financial interest in the outcome. The Chancellor's orders would therefore be set aside as such, but those of the Vice-Chancellor (to the same effect) were confirmed. NB does not matter whether or not financial interest could actually be proved. The mere hint of financial interest is sufficient.

In respect of other kinds of bias (sex, social background, opinions etc) the applicant must show “a real likelihood of bias”. R v Gough – juror realizes that the brother of the man just convicted was his neighbor after the verdict. Verdict not disturbed because there was no real likelihood of bias.
 R v Bow Street Metropolitan and Stipendary Magistrate and Others, Ex Parte Pinochet Ugarte – One of the Law Lords in the Pinochet was a director at Amnesty International. Amnesty International had made representations in the case. Circumstances gave rise to a “presumption of bias”.

  1. Fair Hearing
Leading Case on this is Ridge v Baldwin – a Policeman dismissed at a committee meeting at which he was not given notice off, or was permitted to make representations at. Held to be contrary to natural justice.
Fair hearing has been held to mean a few things.
  • Right to be given notification of the hearing – Hardie v City of Edingburgh 2000

  • Right to be given reasons for the decision –  R v Secretary of State for Home Affairs, Ex parte Doody 1994 – minister added to the period to which the applicants were elgible for parole without telling them why.  Or Ex Parte Al Fayed – denial of naturalization application without giving reasons.  
  • Right to be given an opportunity to respond to the evidence R v General Medical Council ex parte gupta 2001
  • No right to an oral hearing – Ridge v Baldwin
  • Right to legal representation - Pett v Greyhound Racing Association 1970 – Denning MR
“Its not every man who has the ability to defend himself on his own. He cannot bring out the point in his own favor, or the weakness in the other side. He may be tongue tied, nervous, confused, or wanting in intelligence”.
Two final points –
Judiciary in determining what amounts to a fair hearing, is often anxious to not impose the same standards that would be expected in a court on a tribunal.
There is no common law duty to act fairly – but applicants can rely on a legitimate expectation of fairness where:
    • They have been led to believe that a particular procedure would apply; or
    • The policy guidelines of the tribunal or of that decision gives rise to the expectation of some level of fairness
Remedies for Judicial Review
  • Quashing Orders – nullifies decision made by the authority. R v electricity commissioners, ex parte London electricity joint committee
  • Prohibition Orders – prevents a body from making a decision that may be quashed or destroyed
  • Mandatory – Compels a body to take a particular action
  • Declarations – statements/clarifications of the legal position between the parties
  • Injunctions – orders that can prevent an administrative law body from acting unlawfully M v Home Office
  • Damages – where had the party brought an action in private law in respect of the same matter, he/she could have received damages, damages are also available

Monday, April 18, 2011

Civil Liberties

Civil Liberties

Traditional Protection for human rights was given to parliament and the courts – however the significant overlap between the executive and parliament, parliaments role in this has been somewhat limited. So the protection of rights in the UK have traditionally been the preserve of the courts. The first example we can see of this is the case of Entick v Carrington where the courts held that kings messengers, by exceeding their authority, had committed a trespass. However, there have always been limits to capacity of the common law to perform this role. In 1987 for example, Lord Bridge remarked that  the decision of the House of lords to uphold an interim injunction preventing the sale of the novel “Spycatcher” had severely undermined his confidence in the capacity of the common law to safeguard rights and freedoms essential for a free society (AG v Guardian-Newspapers 1986).

One of the key areas in which the common law has proved inadequate is in the area of equality before the law. The common law has proved inadequate to prevent acts of discrimination and as a result, a series of acts have been passed to prevent various forms of discrimination. These include acts that prevent racial, sexual, and age based discrimination. In addition to this, a number of commissions were established to enforce the rights protections in this areas  such as the Commission for Racial Equality, the Equal Opportunity Commission and the Disability Rights Commission. These commissions were merged to create the Commission for Equality and Human Rights in 2006.

Race Based Discrimination
The first race relations acts were passed in 1965. Their purpose was to prevent discrimination based on the grounds of color race nationality or ethnic origin.  The current act – the Race Relations Amendment Act of 2000, imposes a duty on public officers to eliminate all kinds discrimination. It also extends the authority of the act to the police and makes police chiefs vicariously liable for acts of discrimination that are made by their officers.

What is a Racial Minority?
This has been defined as “an ethnic group with a long shared history and a common geographical origin” also, they should distinctive cultural traditions, common language and religion, common literature and be a minority in a larger society.

Based on this definition, courts have held in Mandla v Dowell Lee (1983) that Sikhs are a distinct racial group, in Seide v Gillette Industries (1980) that Jews are a distinct group and Commission for Racial Equality v Dutton (1989) that Gypsies are a distinct group. However, the court held that Rastafarians do meet the criteria for an ethnic group (Dawkins v Department of Environment 1993)

Rastafarians did not form a separate ethnic group for the purposes of the Race Relations Act 1976, and a Rastafarian who was denied a job as a van driver because he wore his hair long and refused to cut it had not been the victim of racial discrimination as defined in the Act.

Direct and Indirect Discrimination
Direct discrimination includes deliberate act that seek to segregate on the grounds of race and to provide separate facilities for different races, irrespective of the quality of the facilities. To make proving discrimination discrimination easier (there can be other reasons given for, eg rejecting a job application) burden of proof has been shifted to the alleged discriminator.
Indirect discrimination is where a person conducts himself in a manner which is not directly discriminatory but has the indirect effect of causing discrimination. Again, this is difficult to prove, so the burden of proof shifts to the alleged perpetrator of the offence. Examples of this – putting in place school uniforms which ban the wearing of headgear required by particular religions. Mandla v Dowell Lee (1983).

Exceptions to Protection
Certain smaller sizes of businesses are exempted from the Act. Also, there are exemptions to allow authenticity – i.e. Indian restaurants are permitted to hire only Indian waiters.

Sexual Discrimination
This has a long history and manifests itself in many forms – absence of the ability to own property, worse pay for women, sanctioning of marital rape etc. It can be both direct and indirect. Indirect is where conditions of employment include certain specifications that exclude women –
e.g. certain height requirements.

There are a number of statutes that have been put in place to correct sexual discrimination – These include the Equal Pay Act 1970 and the Sex Discrimination Act 1975. These are designed to provide protections in the area of employment discrimination for women. They make it illegal to discriminate either by way of sex or marital status in the context of employment.

More recently,  the adoption by the EC of Council Directive 2000/78 (the Employment Directive) required the UK to introduce legislation  prohibiting discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation and religion or belief, which it did in the form of the Employment Equality (Sexual Orientation) Regulations 2003 (SO Regs) and the Employment Equality (Religion or Belief) Regulations 2003 (the RB Regs).  The same Directive resulted in the introduction of significant amendments to the DDA which have served to bring that Act broadly into line with the other legislation insofar as it deals with employment, and will in 2006 result in the regulation of age discrimination in the employment context. The RRA has been amended to give effect to the Race Directive (Council Directive 2000/43) and in October 2005 the SDA was amended to give effect to the Equal Treatment Amending Directive (Council Directive 2002/73).

Burden of Proof
The burden of proof is on the woman to show that but for her gender she would have been treated more favorably. I.e. it rests on the complainant. This was determined by the case Nelson v Carillion Services Ltd (2003).  


EG Home Office v Saunders – prison rules bar men from searching female prisoners, but allow women to search male prisoners.
Ratcliffe v North Yorkshire Council – made women redundant, rehired them at less pay – left men untouched.
Pregnant Women:  Webb v EMO Cargo 1992  – woman had been dismissed from work because she was pregnant. House of Lords held that the dismissal was justified because if she had been a man who had a temporary disability she would also have been dismissed. She appealed to the ECJ who held that being pregnant was unlike having a male illness as it was not pathological/medical. Also, pregnancy was just a temporary impairment.

Gender discrimination rules also apply when men are unfairly treated. For example in the case of R v Sec of State for Employment Ex Parte EOC (1995), where it was held that if a man was elgible for redundancy payment, it  would be discriminatory if women were not eligible for the same treatment.

Recently, strides have been made to recognize the rights of transgender persons. E.g. Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police v A 2004 where it was held that a man who had a sex change operation can be employed as a woman. However, in Bellinger v Bellinger, the court ruled that a marriage between a man and a male to female transsexual was void. The Gender Recognition Act has put in place a process for determining gender through a panel which includes both Drs and lawyers. Once gender is satisfactorily shown, one is granted a certificate.  Being declared a different gender does not affect parental rights and responsibilities.

Sexual Harassment is also prohibited by the sex discrimination Act , which prohibits conduct of a sexual nature or other conduct based on sex affecting the dignity of men and women at work”  e.g. a sexist comment directed at a female firefighter in Hereford and Worcester Council v Clayton 1976. 

Also, HL has held that a tort exists in nuisance to prevent constant unwanted phone-calls from a former boyfriend. Khorasandjian v Bush (1993)

Disability and Discrimination
The Disability Act was passed in Parliament in 1995, and amended in 1999 to create the Commission on Disability. A person has a disability under the act where he or she has a mental of physical impairment which has a substantial and long term adverse effect on his or her ability to carry out normal day to day activities.    It however allows employers to discriminate in favor of disabled people
Archibald v Fife Council 2004 – where it as lawful for an employer to promote a recently disabled employee to a more sedentary post without competing for it.
Compare this to the case of O’Hanlon v Revenue and Customs Commsioners 2006, in which a disabled person was dismissed after lengthy periods of sick leave caused in part by his disability. The employer would have treated any employee the same way in those circumstances.

Freedom of Association and Assembly

The HRA 1998, the ECHR Provides in article 11 that:
Article 11Freedom of assembly and association
1Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and to freedom of association with others, including the right to form and to join trade unions for the protection of his interests.
2No restrictions shall be placed on the exercise of these rights other than such as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security or public safety, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others. This Article shall not prevent the imposition of lawful restrictions on the exercise of these rights by members of the armed forces, of the police or of the administration of the State.
Note that this provision includes a number of exceptions to this broad rule.
Freedom of Association allows a citizens to join any club or society etc – provided that they are not military or quasi military organizations.
R v Jordan and Tyndall (1963) prohibition put in place against persons who were members of fascist group as statute (Public Order Act 1936) prevents the creation of groups of a military or quasi – military nature.

Freedom of Assembly
This is a right that is now heavily regulated by statute, both directly and indirectly. This is not surprising – this is a right that is largely created by statute. There are a number of direct and indirect restrictions to Freedom of Assembly.

Direct Restrictions – where there are direct restrictions on the right to assembly – e.g. on private property where there is no right of public access. Also at certain landmarks such as t Trafalgar Square where permission must be granted by the Secretary of State for the Environment.

Indirect Restrictions
Indirectly, public meetings can be restricted because they constitute a breach of the peace, or that they are obstructing police officers or a public highway.

Breach of the peace:
What is it?
 “a breach of peace occurs whenever harm is actually done, or threatened to be done, to a person or in his presence to his property. R v Howell 1982;

“there is a breach of the peace whenever a person who is lawfully carrying out his work is unlawfully and physically prevented by another from doing so. R v Chief Constable of Devon and Cornwall, Ex Parte Central Electricity Generating Board (1982)

Examples
Beatty v Gillbanks 1882 – cannot be held responsible for the unlawful acts of rival protestors (but see Nicol v Director of Public Prosecutions (1996) where the protestors were trying to provoke the anglers.
Redmond-Bate v DPP 1999– Women Preachers arrested while preaching to a hostile crowd.  Held that free speech was to be protected as long as it did not encourage violence.

There does not have to be proximity for there to be breach – Moss v McLachlan 1985 – miners arrested 4 miles away from a protest that they intended to join. See also R v Chief Constable of Gloucestershire Constabulary 2004 – on their way to protest at an airbase – it was reasonable to stop them from protesting, but to escort them back to London was disproportionate.

Appleby v UK 2003 right of assembly must take into regard the rights of property owners.

Obstructing the Police
Under the Police Act, it is an offence to assault a constable in the performance of his duty, or obstruct a constable in the conduct of his duty.

Also an offence to obstruct a highway. But there actually has to be an obstruction of the highway – cannot be hypothetical.DPP v Jones 1999.

Public Order Acts 1986
Passed as a response to riots, demonstrations and football hooliganism. Aim was to control disorderly conduct and to control demonstrations. Amended by:
  • Criminal Justice and Public Order Act and Also
  • Crime and Disorder Act.

What is Public?
Defined as “any highway”
Any place to which at the material time, the public or any section of the public has access on payment or otherwise, as of right by virtue of express or implied permission.

Requirement of notice – there has to be at least 6 clear days – except where its impractical to do so (this allows for more spontaneous demos. Police may impose conditions or ban processions, but must obtain consent from Home Secretary or local authority before a ban can put in place.
Police may enter private meetings where they reasonably expect a breach of the peace to occur.

Offences under the Public Order Act include:
  • Riot (12 or more persons present together threaten to use violence  for a common purpose), Violent Disorder (3 people, can include threat of violent conduct, enough to cause a reasonable person to fear for his safety),
  • Affray (uses or threatens unlawful violence towards another and his conduct is such as would cause a person of reasonable firmness present at the scene to fear for his personal safety) ,
  • Fear of Provocation of Violence (using threatening or insulting words to another),
  • Harassment, Alarm or Distress (threatening abusive or insulting words, or displays signs showing signs with threatening insulting writings, causing harassment, alarm and distress)

Freedom of Expression and Privacy

This is necessary in any democratic society and has long been recognized as an important right in the UK democratic system. It allows an individual to express any view he or she wishes, however offensive to others they might be. It’s a necessary ideal for any democracy – without it, it would be difficult to hold democratic governments accountable.

Freedom of Speech has existed in the UK, but was first codified by the HRA.

Article 10Freedom of expression
1Everyone has the right to freedom of expression. This right shall include freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas without interference by public authority and regardless of frontiers. This Article shall not prevent States from requiring the licensing of broadcasting, television or cinema enterprises.
2The exercise of these freedoms, since it carries with it duties and responsibilities, may be subject to such formalities, conditions, restrictions or penalties as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society, in the interests of national security, territorial integrity or public safety, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, for the protection of the reputation or rights of others, for preventing the disclosure of information received in confidence, or for maintaining the authority and impartiality of the judiciary.

Note the restrictions that the HRA provides in respect of Freedom of Speech.
Based on these restrictions, there are restrictions against Sedition (“incite violence of public disturbance or disorder” against the government), Incitement to Disaffection (trying to dissuade members of the military from serving) and Treason (“giving aid and comfort to kings enemies); Also there are statutes prevent the publication of material that stirs up racial or religious hatred (“the Racial and Religious Hatred Act 2006”).

It works in interesting ways – but there is always a tension about when freedom of speech has gone too far, for example, in the two case of R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, Ex Parte Simms, it was held that a blanket restriction on prisoners to give interviews to a journalist to investigate what he considered to be the miscarriage of justice occasioned by his imprisonment was unlawful.

However, in R v Governor of Full Sutton Prison (2004), it was held that a rule preventing a prisoner from publishing material about his offences did not violate the right to freedom of expression. Prisoners should not be permitted to glorify the pleasure that his crime caused him”

It is important to note that the right to expression, as provided by the act, does not create a right to access to information:

R v Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (2002); This decision confirmed earlier decisions which had held that governments are not required to hold certain kinds of public enquiries in public.

There are three accepted restrictions to Freedom of Speech: These are:

  • Defamation
  • Obscenity
  • Privacy

Defamation
Sim v Stretch (1936) publication whether oral or written of a falsehood which damages the reputation of the person concerned and lowers the victim’s reputation in the eyes of “right thinking members of the society” Two kinds exist:
  • Slander - spoken
  • Libel - written

It can be civil or criminal, but criminal defamation is very rare. This is primarily a civil action brought in tort. Key to the constitution of this offence is that offending statements must be “published” – this can happen in a number of ways – including through the internet etc.
Defences to Defamation

Truth – self explanatory
Fair comment – the information is on a matter of public interest and consists of factual statements.
Unintentional – if the publication of the statement was made accidentally, and there have attempts to make amends
Absolute Privilege
Though the words are libellous, they are exempted from the law of defamation by statute – e.g.
if they are spoken in parliament, or in the course of judicial proceedings.
Qualified Privilege
Also a protection against statements that are ordinarily libellous, but the protections here are not absolute. They must be made without malice. And the matter should be one of public interest (Jameel v Wall Street Journal 2006)

Obscenity
This is governed by the Obscene Publications Act, 1959, creates an offence for the publication of obscene writings. Publication occurs when a person “distributes, sells, lets, hires, gives or lends it”.  It must “deprave or corrupt”. However there is no legal prohibition against pornography.

Privacy
Also not stated clearly by common law or statute. Stated in the negative rather than the positive. Various other rules imply it rather it being stated outright!

But now provided for under the Human Rights Act
Article 8Right to respect for private and family life
1Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home and his correspondence.
2There shall be no interference by a public authority with the exercise of this right except such as is in accordance with the law and is necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security, public safety or the economic well-being of the country, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.

Examples of the right to privacy.

Individual Privacy - Malone v UK (1984) court complains that the absence of rules governing listening to private conversations was problematic.

Family – Campbell v Mirror Group Papers – privacy weighed against public’s right to know. Therefore publicizing pictures od plaintiff leaving rehab centre was a breach